top of page

Behind the Investigations

Research, realism, and the challenges of writing a police procedural

An Interest in How Investigations Work


I've always enjoyed mysteries, crime dramas, and police procedurals. There's something interesting about watching an investigation unfold, particularly when the story allows you to follow the evidence, understand the decisions investigators are making, and gradually discover what actually happened.


My interest in criminal investigations, however, went beyond watching television or reading mysteries. During college, I took Criminal Investigations I and II, Fingerprint Science, and several other courses related to criminal justice and investigative procedures. Those classes gave me an academic foundation in the subject and helped me understand many of the principles involved in conducting an investigation.


That background was one of the things I brought with me when I began developing Father's Day. I wasn't simply interested in creating a crime and having a detective identify the person responsible. I wanted to explore the investigation itself, including the questions that arise along the way, the people involved in finding answers, and the decisions that eventually lead toward a resolution.


Of course, studying criminal investigations and writing a believable police procedural are two different things. When I began developing Father's Day, I discovered that there was a considerable difference between understanding investigative principles and figuring out how those principles would actually be applied in the situations I was creating.


I had ideas about the crimes, the characters, and the direction of the story. What I needed to understand was how to connect those ideas through an investigation that made sense.
 

Investigations Book

Fundamentals of Criminal Investigation — the textbook I used in college.

TV Shows

Television Doesn't Always Get It Right

One of the things I've noticed over the years is how quickly investigations tend to move on television. Evidence is collected, submitted to a laboratory, analyzed, and returned in what sometimes feels like a matter of hours. Investigators obtain warrants with very little difficulty, interviews produce exactly the information needed, and the right piece of evidence often appears just in time to move the story forward.


I understand why television works that way. A crime drama has a limited amount of time to tell its story, and watching investigators wait several weeks for laboratory results probably isn't going to make particularly exciting television. But when I began writing Father's Day, I knew I didn't want every part of the investigation to happen simply because the next chapter needed something to happen.


If evidence required laboratory analysis, I wanted to account for the time involved. If investigators needed a search warrant, there had to be a reasonable basis for obtaining one. If Duke Mantz reached a conclusion, I wanted readers to understand how he arrived there rather than accepting it because he happened to be the detective at the center of the story.


That doesn't mean every procedure needs to be described in exhaustive detail. A novel still has to be entertaining, and there are times when spending several pages explaining a routine process would do little to improve the story. The challenge is deciding which details matter and making sure the investigation remains believable without becoming a procedural manual.
 

Starting With the Crime

One of the more interesting challenges I've encountered is that developing a mystery often requires me to think about the crime from a completely different perspective than the one readers will experience.


The reader generally follows Duke Mantz and the other investigators as they discover information. But as the writer, I need to understand what happened before the investigation began. Who was involved? What decisions did they make? What evidence might have been left behind? What did someone attempt to conceal, and what mistakes might eventually bring the truth to light?


Those questions become the foundation of the investigation. I may already know the circumstances surrounding a crime, but Duke doesn't. He has to discover them through the evidence available to him, the people he interviews, and the conclusions he can reasonably draw from what he's learned.


That distinction is important because it's surprisingly easy to allow a character to act on information that only the writer knows. I might understand exactly why a suspect behaved a certain way, but unless Duke has discovered something that points him in that direction, he has no reason to reach the same conclusion.


Much of my work involves making sure the information reaches the investigators in an order that makes sense. Sometimes that requires moving a scene, changing a conversation, or reconsidering how a particular piece of evidence is discovered. The solution may already be clear in my mind, but the investigation still has to earn its way there.
 

The Crime Scene Comes First

​

Crime scenes have become one of the areas where I pay particular attention to detail. They're often the starting point for an investigation, and what happens during those first few hours can affect everything that follows.


When writing a crime scene, I have to consider more than what investigators discover. I need to think about who arrived first, what they observed, whether anyone disturbed the scene, and what steps would be taken to preserve potential evidence. Even the route someone takes into or out of an area can become important.


I've spent a considerable amount of time working through those questions while developing After the Search. The discovery that begins the investigation involves a survey crew working on a parcel of land. That means I have to consider what the workers were doing before they discovered something suspicious, where their equipment was positioned, how they moved through the area, and what happens once law enforcement arrives.


Those details might seem relatively minor when compared with the larger mystery, but they're important to the credibility of the scene. Investigators can't simply begin moving things around because doing so would make it easier for me to describe what they've found. They have to approach the situation in a way that respects the possibility that they're dealing with evidence.


I've discovered that working through those practical questions can actually make a scene more interesting. Instead of rushing directly to the discovery, I can allow the uncertainty to develop naturally as the characters begin recognizing that something isn't right.
 

Core Characters

Investigations Are a Team Effort

​

Another thing I've tried to avoid is turning Duke Mantz into the kind of fictional detective who somehow knows everything and can accomplish every part of an investigation by himself.


Duke is an experienced investigator, but that doesn't mean he's a forensic scientist, a medical examiner, a prosecutor, and a crime scene technician all rolled into one. He has his own training and experience, and so do the people around him.


Characters such as Amy Novak and Dr. Sunny Delgado bring knowledge and responsibilities to an investigation that Duke doesn't possess. Vin Caruso and the patrol officers may be involved long before a detective arrives. Other professionals contribute information and expertise as the investigation develops.


I want those contributions to matter. If Amy identifies something important during evidence processing, that discovery should come from her work rather than Duke conveniently noticing everything first. If Sunny provides medical findings, those conclusions need to reflect her professional responsibilities. And if Vin or another officer makes an observation at a scene, that information can become just as important as something Duke discovers later.


That approach also creates opportunities for the characters to interact in ways that feel natural. They can discuss possibilities, disagree about interpretations, ask questions, and sometimes recognize that they don't yet have enough information to reach a conclusion.


To me, that's more interesting than having one detective announce the answer while everyone else stands around waiting for instructions.
 

Researching What I Don't Know

​

One of the things writing police procedurals has taught me is how often I need to stop and research something I initially thought I understood.


My college coursework gave me a foundation in criminal investigations, but there's a difference between learning investigative principles in a classroom and understanding how everything works in practice. I could study the procedures, understand the concepts, and pass the examinations, but that didn't mean I knew every practical detail of how investigators handled situations in the field. There were still plenty of things I hadn't experienced or fully understood, particularly when it came to the day-to-day realities of conducting an investigation.


That's something I've become increasingly aware of while writing the Falcon Hollow mysteries. My education gives me a starting point, but it doesn't eliminate the need for research. If anything, it helps me recognize when I need to look more closely at a particular procedure rather than simply assuming I already know how it works.


Sometimes it's a question about evidence collection or the responsibilities of a particular agency. Other times it involves legal procedures, medical findings, investigative timelines, or the practical details of how officers would respond to a particular situation.
There are also questions that arise because Falcon Hollow is a small community. Its police department doesn't have unlimited personnel or resources, so I have to think about what its officers can reasonably handle and when assistance from other agencies might become necessary.


I don't always know the answers when I begin writing a scene. Occasionally, I'll develop an exchange or sequence of events that sounds perfectly reasonable until I examine it more closely. Then I discover that a procedure doesn't work the way I imagined, a character wouldn't have access to certain information, or something would take considerably longer than I'd allowed.
When that happens, I have to make adjustments. Sometimes the solution is relatively simple. Other times, correcting one detail affects several scenes because the investigation depends on what happened earlier.


Research doesn't eliminate every mistake, and I certainly don't claim to be an expert in every subject that appears in these books. But I do think there's a responsibility to make a reasonable effort, particularly when the story involves professions and procedures that readers may know from personal experience.
 

When the Investigation Changes the Story

​

Something I didn't fully appreciate when I began writing Father's Day was how much an investigation could influence the direction of the story itself.


I might begin with a particular sequence of events in mind, only to discover that the evidence wouldn't reasonably lead investigators where I wanted them to go. A witness might not know something I'd originally planned for them to reveal. A conversation might happen too early, or a piece of evidence might require additional work before anyone could understand its significance.


Those discoveries sometimes force me to reconsider the structure of the mystery. It's tempting to keep a scene simply because I like the way it's written, but if the investigation doesn't support what happens in that scene, it becomes a problem.


That's one of the reasons revision has become such a large part of my writing process. I'm not only looking at dialogue, descriptions, and pacing. I'm also checking whether the investigation follows a logical progression and whether each new development is supported by what came before it.


And sometimes the changes improve the story in ways I hadn't anticipated. A delay can create uncertainty. An unanswered question can lead to another line of inquiry. A discovery that seemed straightforward at first can become more complicated once the investigators begin examining it.


The investigation isn't simply something that happens between the beginning and end of a mystery. It helps determine how the story develops.
 

Finding the Balance Between Realism and Storytelling

​

For all the attention I give to procedure, I try to remember that I'm writing fiction. Readers aren't picking up a Falcon Hollow mystery because they want to study a police department's operating procedures. They're looking for a story, characters they can connect with, and an investigation that keeps them interested in what happens next.


That means finding a balance. I want enough procedural detail to make the investigation believable, but not so much that the story becomes buried beneath explanations. I want investigators to encounter realistic obstacles without making every chapter about paperwork, scheduling, or waiting for information.


I also want to remember that the people involved in an investigation are more than their roles in a case. Victims have lives that existed before the crime. Witnesses have their own concerns and reasons for becoming involved. Even the people responsible for criminal acts have histories and motivations that may be important to understanding what happened.


That was particularly important to me as Father's Day evolved. The story became about more than identifying the person responsible for a series of crimes. I wanted to explore the human circumstances surrounding those events while still maintaining the importance of accountability.


I don't believe realism and storytelling have to compete with one another. When they're working together, the procedures support the story, and the story gives those procedures meaning.
 

Still Learning With Every Investigation

​

When I think about how much has changed since I first began writing Father's Day, one of the biggest differences is the amount of attention I now give to the investigation before deciding that a scene is finished.


I still approach stories with ideas arriving in no particular order. I may know how a crime occurred long before I've worked out how Duke will discover the truth. I may have a conversation in mind without knowing exactly where it belongs. And I still occasionally find myself revisiting something I wrote several chapters earlier because a new detail has changed the way I understand the case.


But I've become more willing to question those ideas and take the time to work through them. I've learned that getting the investigation right often means slowing down, asking more questions, and accepting that the first version of a scene may not be the one that belongs in the finished manuscript.


With After the Search, I'm continuing that process. Each new investigation presents different circumstances, different challenges, and new things for me to learn. I don't expect to reach a point where I know everything there is to know about writing a police procedural, and I'm not sure I'd want to.


What I do want is for readers to feel that the investigations in Falcon Hollow unfold for believable reasons. I want them to understand why Duke and the others make the decisions they do, recognize that the answers aren't always obvious, and see the people behind the evidence.


Because for me, the most interesting part of writing a mystery isn't simply knowing who committed the crime.
It's figuring out how the investigators are going to discover the truth.

 

bottom of page