AI Helped Me Write My Books. They're Still My Stories.

Updated: 5 days ago
Beyond the Manuscript | Finding My Voice Through AI-Assisted Writing
There's a fairly common argument floating around these days that if you use artificial
intelligence to help write a book, you're not really an author.
I've heard variations of it. AI wrote the book. All you did was type a few prompts. You let a computer do the work and put your name on the cover.
I can understand why people have concerns about AI-generated writing. I've seen some pretty awful examples myself. But there's something missing from that argument, and it's something I know from personal experience.
Not everyone who has a story to tell can sit down and turn it into a book.
And sometimes, the problem has absolutely nothing to do with imagination.
The Stories Were Never the Problem
I've never had much trouble coming up with ideas. Give me a subject that interests me, and I can research it, talk about it, and probably spend more time discussing it than anyone around me wants to hear.
My problem has always been getting those thoughts organized long enough to write them down.

I can sit at a keyboard just fine. The physical act of writing has never been the issue. But concentrating on one subject long enough to turn it into a coherent chapter? That's another story.
I might start writing a scene with a perfectly clear idea of where I want it to go. A sentence or two later, another thought pops into my head. Then another. Before I know it, I've wandered so far from the original subject that I might as well be writing an entirely different chapter.
When I go back and read what I've written, there can be five or six different ideas competing for attention.
And somehow, I'm supposed to make a coherent story out of that.
This isn't something that started when I began writing books.
I had the same difficulty in college.
Researching a paper was never particularly troublesome. I could find the material, study it, and understand what I wanted to explain. But getting everything organized and written down could take forever.
I'd write for a while, get up, walk around, come back, write a little more, and repeat the process. An assignment that should have taken a couple of days could consume every minute I had available.
I can remember sitting in the campus cafeteria finishing the last part of an assignment because I was running out of time.
It wasn't that I hadn't been working on it.
I'd been working on it the entire time.
I just couldn't keep my thoughts moving in one direction long enough to finish.
Grammar and punctuation weren't exactly my strongest subjects, either. And if you've read much of my writing, you've probably noticed that I don't have a particularly impressive collection of five-dollar words.
I tend to write the way I talk.
For better or worse, that's my voice.
The Book That Changed Things
My introduction to AI-assisted writing didn't begin with Falcon Hollow.
It began with Echo Chamber Evangelist.
I'd spent considerable time researching persuasion and the ways people can be influenced by information that reinforces what they already believe. I became particularly interested in how those techniques appeared in the flat-Earth movement.
I wanted to explore why people could become convinced by claims that contradicted established scientific evidence, and how certain advocates presented themselves as knowledgeable authorities.
I had the research. I had the ideas. I knew what I wanted the book to explain.
Then came the familiar problem.
How was I going to organize all of that into something somebody could actually read?
That's when I began experimenting with AI.
Instead of trying to wrestle every thought into place by myself, I could discuss the material. I could explain what I was trying to accomplish, bounce ideas around, and work through how the chapters should fit together.
If I wandered away from the subject, I could return to the discussion and work my way back.
AI helped me develop the chapter structure, organize the material, and eventually format and assemble the book.
For the first time, I had a practical way to work through a problem that had followed me for years.
I remember thinking that I should have kicked myself in the backside for not having something like this when I was in college.
Then again, I'm glad I didn't.
Working through those college assignments the hard way taught me quite a bit, even if I spent an unreasonable amount of time walking around trying to get my thoughts together.
But Echo Chamber Evangelist showed me something I hadn't really considered before.
Maybe I could write books after all.
Not because AI suddenly gave me ideas.
Because it helped me organize the ideas I already had.
From Research to Falcon Hollow
Once I realized what AI could do for my nonfiction writing, I started thinking about fiction.
That eventually led to Father's Day and the fictional town of Falcon Hollow, Maryland.
I didn't begin with an empty screen and ask AI to invent a detective, a town, and a murder mystery for me.
I had a story I wanted to tell.
I had ideas about the kind of detective I wanted at the center of it. Duke Mantz wasn't going to be another stereotypical broken investigator whose entire personality revolved around tragedy and misery.
He would have difficulties in his past. Those experiences would affect him. But they wouldn't be the only things that defined him.
Before I began writing Father's Day, I already had a pretty solid understanding of who Duke was.
As the books progressed, he continued to develop. Known by Another Name allowed him to grow, and Falcon Hollow Origins: Duke Mantz helped establish the personal history behind the man readers had already met.
Along the way, other characters began taking on more substantial roles. Lou Whitman became more than a convenient source of information. Amy Novak developed her own distinctive relationship with Duke. Vin Caruso became an important part of the police department and Duke's professional life.
And I found myself building an entire fictional community around them.
AI helped me work through that development, but the creative decisions remained mine.
Which brings me to something that happened recently.
When My Own AI Assistant Got the Story Wrong
I was working on another Behind the Manuscript article about how my characters developed over time.
During our conversation, my AI assistant began describing Duke's development in a way that suggested AI had essentially created him and that I had gradually discovered who he was.
That wasn't what happened.
So I stopped the conversation and corrected it.
Duke was already largely established before Father's Day. His personality drew on earlier character ideas, qualities I admired, and parts of my own experiences.
The later books gave him a fuller history, but they didn't create his personality from nothing.
And that led to a bigger realization.
If my own AI assistant could make my writing process sound as though I was simply feeding it ideas and letting it create everything, imagine how easily someone unfamiliar with the process could reach the same conclusion.
That's when I decided this subject deserved an article of its own.
Because there's a difference between using AI to help write a book and handing over every creative decision to AI.
And that difference matters.
The Part Readers Don't See
One of the things I've learned about AI-assisted writing is that a scene can be perfectly readable and still be completely wrong.
I've had scenes where Duke sounded nothing like Duke.
I've had conversations where Vin Caruso seemed to be directing an investigation instead of contributing his experience as a fellow officer.
In After the Search, there was a conversation during a drive to Hancock where Duke was supposed to share some investigative experience with Vin.
The problem was that the exchange started sounding like a teacher lecturing a student.
That wasn't their relationship.
Both men were experienced police officers. Duke had investigative knowledge to share, but Vin wasn't some inexperienced rookie sitting through a training session.
So the conversation needed to change.
Other times, the problem has been much larger.
While working on Known by Another Name, I encountered a characterization shift so significant that repairing a few lines wasn't going to solve it.
We had to discard the material and start over.
And that's something I want readers to understand.
Just because AI produces a scene doesn't mean I accept it.
Sometimes I make small corrections. Sometimes I rewrite substantial portions. Sometimes an otherwise usable scene goes straight into the trash because it doesn't belong in the story I'm trying to tell.
I make those decisions.
AI doesn't.
Why I Built a Reference Library
As Falcon Hollow grew, I discovered that I needed more than individual character notes and a few reminders about where things were located.
I needed a way to keep an increasingly complicated fictional world consistent.
That led to the reference library I use today.
It includes a Character Bible, World Bible, Canon document, Editorial Guide, geographic references, timelines, and other materials that establish how Falcon Hollow works.
These documents help AI maintain continuity, but they serve another purpose.
They preserve my decisions.
They establish who the characters are, how they behave, where they live, how the police department operates, and what has already happened in the stories.
They also help protect the writing style I've worked to establish.
I've spent a considerable amount of time correcting prose that sounds too polished, too dramatic, or simply too much like AI.
I don't want every character speaking as though they've swallowed a dictionary.
And I certainly don't want Duke delivering a philosophical speech every time somebody asks him a question.
The reference library helps keep the writing grounded in the world I've created.
But it isn't foolproof.
I still have to read the material, recognize when something doesn't fit, and decide what needs to change.
There's no reference document that can replace that responsibility.
Why I Need the Help
There's a personal side to this that I haven't discussed much in my writing.
I've lived with PTSD since 2004.
It's part of my life, and dealing with it hasn't always been easy.
One of the difficulties I've experienced over the years is maintaining the concentration needed to organize complicated thoughts into sustained writing.
I don't want to suggest that everyone living with PTSD experiences the same thing. I'm describing my own circumstances.
For me, the challenge isn't a lack of ideas or an inability to understand what I'm writing about.
It's keeping everything organized long enough to get it onto the page.
And AI has given me a way to work around some of those difficulties.
I can discuss a scene instead of struggling to hold every detail in my head. I can work through the structure of a chapter, consider different approaches, and return to the original subject when my thoughts start wandering.
Sometimes the conversation itself helps me recognize what I actually want to say.
That doesn't mean the process is effortless.
Anyone who has spent time watching me develop Falcon Hollow would probably laugh at that suggestion.
There are days when I spend hours correcting something that should have been simple. There are conversations where AI and I go around in circles because it keeps misunderstanding what I want.
And there are moments when I wonder whether the computer and I are speaking the same language.
But I can keep working.
I can move forward.
And most importantly, I can finish the stories I want to tell.
Without that assistance, I genuinely don't know whether those stories would ever have made it into books.
So, Am I Still an Author?
I know there are people who will disagree with my approach.
Some believe that any substantial use of AI in drafting a manuscript disqualifies someone from calling themselves an author.
They're entitled to that opinion.
I'm not writing this article to convince everyone that AI-assisted writing is the right choice. Nor am I suggesting that writing a novel with AI is the same process as writing every word without assistance.
It isn't.
AI contributes to my writing process, including helping develop and draft prose. I'm not going to pretend otherwise.
But I also won't pretend that the stories, characters, creative decisions, revisions, and countless hours of work somehow disappear because I use that assistance.
I decide what happens in Falcon Hollow.
I decide who Duke Mantz is.
I decide whether a scene works, whether a character's behavior makes sense, and whether a chapter belongs in the finished manuscript.
And ultimately, I'm responsible for the books that carry my name.
To me, that's an essential part of being an author.
Maybe You Have a Story, Too
There's another reason I wanted to write this article, and it's probably the most important one.
Somewhere out there, I suspect there's somebody who has a wonderful story to tell.
Maybe they've been carrying it around for years.
Maybe they can sit with friends and describe the characters, the setting, and everything that happens. Maybe they can tell the story so well that everyone listening wants to know what happens next.
But when they sit down to write it, something gets in the way.
Maybe it's difficulty concentrating. Maybe it's organizing their thoughts. Maybe it's a disability, a medical condition, or some other obstacle that makes traditional writing difficult.
Whatever the reason, they've convinced themselves that writing a book simply isn't something they can do.
I know something about that feeling.
And I also know that having trouble getting a story onto the page doesn't necessarily mean you don't have a story worth telling.
AI isn't a magic solution. It won't automatically make somebody a good writer, and it certainly won't eliminate the need for creative judgment, patience, or revision.
But it might give someone a way to begin.
It gave me one.
I started with a nonfiction book about persuasion and conspiracy theories. That experience eventually led me to a fictional Maryland town, a detective named Duke Mantz, and stories I might never have finished otherwise.
So if you're someone who has always wanted to write but has struggled to find a way to do it, perhaps there's another approach worth exploring.
You still have to bring the ideas, the imagination, and the willingness to do the work.
You still have to decide what you want your story to be.
But you don't necessarily have to struggle through every part of the process alone.
AI helped me put my stories into words. It didn't decide which stories I wanted to tell.
And if sharing that experience encourages even one person to finally start writing the story they've been carrying around, then this article has done exactly what I hoped it would.





Comments