top of page
Search

When Characters Started Having Lives of Their Own

Writer: D. Patrick Dillon
D. Patrick Dillon
2 days ago
9 min read

Beyond the Manuscript | How the People of Falcon Hollow Grew Beyond Their Original Roles


When I started writing Father's Day, I wasn't planning an entire series of novels about Falcon Hollow.

I wanted to write a police procedural. I needed a detective, a police chief, patrol officers, a prosecutor, forensic specialists, and the other people you would expect to encounter during a murder investigation.

Naturally, I had to figure out who these people were. They couldn't all be interchangeable names who appeared whenever the story needed somebody to answer a telephone or deliver a piece of evidence.

But I certainly wasn't planning their lives ten years into the future.

I was trying to write one book.

Somewhere along the way, that changed.

And before I knew it, I had characters who seemed to have opinions about what they would and wouldn't do.

Which can be rather inconvenient when you're the person trying to write the story.


Duke Was Already Duke


One thing I want to make clear is that Duke Mantz didn't start out as an empty character waiting for me to figure out who he was.

Before I began writing Father's Day, I already had a pretty good understanding of his personality. I'd say roughly 75 to 80 percent of Duke was established before the first chapter.

I'd spent time thinking about the qualities I admired in characters from shows like NCIS. Gibbs, DiNozzo, and McGee all had characteristics that interested me, although I wasn't looking to copy any of them.

I wanted a detective with his own personality.

I also drew on ideas from an earlier character I'd developed, along with some of my own sense of humor, values, and ways of approaching problems.

Duke wasn't going to be the stereotypical broken detective whose entire personality revolved around tragedy.

He had experienced difficulties. His past affected him. But there was more to him than that.

I knew how I wanted him to think, how he would approach an investigation, and how he would interact with other people.

What I didn't have was every detail of his life worked out.

That came later.

As I wrote Known by Another Name, Duke continued to develop. Then Falcon Hollow Origins: Duke Mantz gave me an opportunity to explore the experiences that had shaped the detective readers already knew.

His childhood, military service, family relationships, and early law enforcement career helped explain why he behaved the way he did.

In a sense, Origins didn't create Duke.

It helped me understand him more completely.

And that's something I've come to appreciate about writing a continuing character. You can know who somebody is without knowing everything that happened to make them that way.


The Woman Who Was Supposed to Know Everything


Lou Whitman is probably one of my favorite examples of a supporting character becoming more important than I originally intended.

Lou owns the Cedar Street Cafe.

When I first introduced her, she had a fairly straightforward purpose. In a small town, a cafe owner is likely to hear things. People come in, have breakfast, drink coffee, and talk.

For a detective, somebody like Lou can be a useful source of information.

That was essentially her original role.

But as I worked with her character, something else began to emerge.

Lou wasn't simply a woman who knew what everybody in Falcon Hollow was doing. She cared about the people who walked through her door.

And she cared about Duke.

That gave their relationship a warmth I hadn't necessarily planned when I first needed somebody who might know a little town gossip.

Lou became somebody I wanted to keep around.

Not because every investigation needed another conversation at the cafe, but because she had become part of Duke's everyday life.

That's a distinction I hadn't fully appreciated when I began writing Father's Day.

A character doesn't have to contribute directly to solving a murder to contribute something important to the story.

Sometimes a character simply makes the world feel more like a place where people actually live.


Detective Stoic and the Caffeine Fairy


Amy Novak developed in a slightly different way.

Amy is Falcon Hollow's forensic specialist, and I wanted her relationship with Duke to have some of the playful contrast I'd enjoyed between Gibbs and Abby on NCIS.

Not the same characters or the same relationship, but that combination of professional respect and occasional humor.

During our early character brainstorming, AI suggested a couple of nicknames.

Duke became “Detective Stoic.”

Amy became “Caffeine Fairy.”

I liked them.

They captured something about the way the two characters interacted, and they helped establish a relationship that could continue beyond one investigation.

Amy could be energetic and playful without becoming unprofessional. Duke could respond with his usual dry humor without suddenly turning into somebody who spent every conversation cracking jokes.

The balance mattered.

And once that relationship was established, I had to maintain it.

That's one of the interesting things about developing recurring characters. A small decision made during brainstorming can become something you need to remember several books later.

Sometimes the smallest details are the ones readers come to associate most strongly with a character.


Vin Wasn't Looking for a Promotion to Detective


Vin Caruso is another character whose role grew considerably.

In Falcon Hollow Origins, Vin is a patrol officer working the swing shift, with call sign 222.

As the stories move forward, he becomes a sergeant and eventually the Patrol Division Supervisor.

But what interests me most about Vin isn't his rank.

It's the fact that he belongs on patrol.

Vin is an experienced officer, a former Marine, and somebody Duke respects. Their friendship and professional relationship have become important parts of the series.

At one point, I considered the possibility of Vin becoming Falcon Hollow's second detective.

On paper, it wasn't a ridiculous idea. He had experience, understood police work, and already had a strong working relationship with Duke.

But the more I considered it, the less it made sense.

Vin loves patrol.

He likes being out on the street, dealing directly with the people and problems that come with the job. Moving into investigations might look like advancement to somebody else, but that doesn't mean Vin would see it that way.

And that's when I realized I couldn't simply move him into a detective's office because it would be convenient for the series.

It wouldn't be Vin.

I haven't written his origin story yet, but I already know one of the things I want readers to understand when I do.

Vin Caruso was born to be a patrolman.

Not every capable officer wants to become a detective, and not every character needs to follow the career path a writer might find convenient.

Sometimes the most interesting decision is the one a character wouldn't make.


Not Everybody Has to Stay


Then there's Brooke Allen.

I enjoyed writing Brooke in Father's Day, and she made enough of an impression that I brought her back for a smaller appearance in Known by Another Name.

But that didn't mean she had to become a permanent member of the cast.

I could have found ways to keep bringing her into the stories. I could have built a larger role around her simply because I liked the character.

But that wasn't necessarily what the stories needed.

I've learned that allowing characters to develop also means knowing when to let them step away.

Some people enter our lives for a relatively short time and still leave an impression.

There's no reason fictional characters can't do the same.

And if Brooke has a reason to return someday, that's something I can consider when the story calls for it.


When Duke Stopped Sounding Like Duke


Of course, developing characters is one thing.

Keeping them consistent is something else entirely.

And this is where writing with AI has occasionally become an exercise in frustration.

I can establish a character's personality, provide the reference documents, discuss exactly what a scene is supposed to accomplish, and still end up reading something that sounds as though an entirely different person has walked into the room.

Sometimes the problem is obvious immediately.

Other times, it doesn't become apparent until I put several scenes together and read the chapter or the entire act.

An individual scene might work perfectly well. The dialogue makes sense. The investigation moves forward. Everybody seems to be doing something useful.

Then I read it in context.

And suddenly Duke isn't Duke anymore.

Maybe he's relying too heavily on Vin to reach an investigative conclusion.

Maybe he's speaking in a way that doesn't fit his personality.

Maybe his judgment or his relationship with another character has shifted.

The writing itself might be fine.

The characterization isn't.

And I've learned that those are two very different things.


Sometimes You Have to Throw It Away


When that happens, I have a decision to make.

If the problem is relatively small, I can repair the scene.

Maybe a conversation needs to be adjusted. Maybe Duke needs to approach a question differently. Maybe a few lines of dialogue are giving the wrong impression.

Those problems can usually be corrected without starting over.

But there have been times when the character drift was so significant that repairing the scene wasn't worth the effort.

That happened during Known by Another Name.

The characterization had moved so far away from what I'd established earlier in the book that the material no longer belonged in the story.

So I discarded it and started again.

I encountered a more subtle problem while working on After the Search.

Duke and Vin were driving to Hancock, and I wanted Duke to share some investigative experience with his friend.

That was perfectly reasonable for their relationship.

But when I read the exchange, it sounded less like two experienced police officers talking and more like an instructor delivering a lesson to a student.

That wasn't what I wanted.

Duke might have more investigative experience, but Vin isn't an inexperienced officer who needs somebody to explain police work to him.

The relationship needed to remain one between colleagues who respect each other.

So the conversation had to change.

That's the kind of thing a character reference sheet can help with, but it can't always prevent.

And it's why I still read, evaluate, and revise the material rather than assuming that a scene is correct simply because it follows the outline.


The Characters Don't Actually Make the Decisions


Writers sometimes say their characters have taken on lives of their own.

I've said it myself.

But I don't mean that literally.

Duke doesn't sit down beside me and tell me what he plans to do next. Vin hasn't actually refused a detective promotion. Lou doesn't call to complain that she hasn't appeared in the last three chapters.

Although, knowing Lou, I wouldn't put it past her.

What I mean is that I've developed these characters well enough to recognize when something doesn't fit.

I know Duke's personality. I understand what motivates Vin. I know why Lou cares about the people around her and how Amy relates to Duke.

That understanding influences the decisions I make while writing.

And sometimes it means abandoning a perfectly reasonable plot idea because it would require a character to behave in a way that doesn't make sense.

AI can suggest a direction.

It can help me explore possibilities, develop conversations, and draft scenes.

But I decide whether those suggestions belong in Falcon Hollow.

Sometimes I accept them.

Sometimes I change them.

And sometimes I throw them out.

That's part of being responsible for the story.


The People Behind the Stories


One of the things that helped inspire Falcon Hollow Origins was a conversation with my sister after she'd read Father's Day.

She wanted to know more about Duke.

How did he get his nickname? Why did he become a detective?

Those were reasonable questions.

And they made me think about how much of Duke's life existed beyond the investigation I'd written.

I had a strong understanding of his personality, but there was an opportunity to explore his past and show readers how he'd become the man they met in Father's Day.

That eventually became an entire novel.

It also reinforced something I'd begun noticing about Falcon Hollow.

The town was no longer just a setting for one murder investigation.

It had become a community filled with people who had jobs, relationships, histories, opinions, and lives that continued whether Duke was investigating a case or not.

Some of those people would remain important to the series. Others might appear only occasionally. A few might have stories worth telling on their own.

And I didn't need to know every one of those stories when I began writing Father's Day.

I just needed to allow the world to grow without losing sight of the people I'd already created.


A Town Full of Possibilities


Looking back, I think that's one of the most satisfying parts of developing Falcon Hollow.

I started with a detective and a murder investigation.

I ended up with a town full of people whose lives extend beyond any single book.

Duke continues to grow as he encounters new experiences. Vin has a career and a history that deserve exploration. Lou, Amy, Brooke, and the other characters have their own places in the community.

And each time I return to Falcon Hollow, I have a better understanding of the people who live there.

That doesn't mean I can make them do whatever I want.

Well, technically I can. I'm the author.

But if I want readers to believe in these characters, their decisions have to make sense.

And that's probably the best way I can explain what it means when I say the characters have started having lives of their own.

They've become real enough in my imagination that I know when the writing gets them wrong.

Even when the writing came from a very helpful AI assistant that was absolutely convinced it had gotten everything right.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page