When AI Couldn't Keep Falcon Hollow Straight

Beyond the Manuscript | Keeping Track of a Town That Didn't Exist
When I first started writing Father's Day, I had absolutely no idea what I was getting myself into. It began with a single sentence about Candice Price leaving a courthouse through the back entrance to avoid a crowd of reporters waiting out front. That was it. One sentence that eventually became the beginning of a mystery novel and, as it turned out, an entire fictional community.

I wasn't sitting at my desk with a carefully developed plan for Falcon Hollow, Maryland. I didn't have a detailed town history, a street directory, or a map showing where everything was supposed to be. I had a story I wanted to tell, a few characters beginning to take shape, and ChatGPT helping me work through the writing.
As the story developed, questions naturally came up. Where was the courthouse? Where did the police department sit in relation to downtown? What did Main Street look like? Was Cedar Street Cafe near the center of town or farther north? Sometimes those questions came from ChatGPT, and sometimes they came from me as I tried to picture the scenes I was writing.
The trouble was that every answer created another detail I needed to remember.
And remembering all those details wasn't exactly going according to plan.
Wait a Minute. Lou Is a Woman.
One of the earliest problems involved Lou Whitman, the owner of Cedar Street Cafe. Lou was a woman. I'd established that. I knew it. But every so often, ChatGPT would decide Lou was a man, presumably because the name Lou is often associated with men.
I'd correct the mistake, we'd continue writing, and eventually it would happen again.
The same thing occurred with locations. A building I'd described on one side of downtown might suddenly appear somewhere else. Street names could change. A familiar business would be described differently from one chapter to another, and I'd find myself stopping to figure out which description we'd originally agreed upon.
Sometimes the problem happened within a conversation. Other times, we'd moved into a new chat, and the details established in the previous one weren't available in the same way. I'd have to explain things again, often without remembering exactly what we'd decided the first time.
But I can't put all the blame on ChatGPT.
I was doing a pretty good job of confusing myself.
I'd remember that Cedar Street Cafe was a corner restaurant, but forget that I'd placed Cedar Street toward the northern end of downtown. Sometimes I'd forget about the Riverwalk entirely. I'd introduce officers at a crime scene and later struggle to remember who was supposed to be there.
And then there were the buildings. Had I already established where that particular business was located? Was it near Main Street or closer to the lake? Had I described that street running north and south, or east and west?
I was making decisions as I wrote, and I wasn't always keeping track of them.
My Imagination Was Moving Faster Than My Notes
One thing about the way my mind works is that it doesn't necessarily travel in a straight line. I might start thinking about A, jump to Z, move backward to R, wander over to Q, and eventually find my way back to B.
That's simply how ideas develop for me.
While working on a chapter, I might start imagining another part of Falcon Hollow. That could lead to questions about the town's geography, which might send me off thinking about a map, or how the town should look on a website. Then another idea would come along, and I'd follow that one for a while.
Eventually, I'd return to the manuscript, having developed several new details about Falcon Hollow along the way.
The problem wasn't a lack of ideas. It was keeping track of the ones I'd already had.
I did write things down occasionally. There were notes in notebooks, bits of information in Word documents, and plenty of details scattered throughout ChatGPT conversations.
Unfortunately, I wasn't particularly organized about any of it.
Anyone who's seen my desk would understand why a notebook could disappear for a day or two. I'd remember writing something down, but finding where I'd written it was another matter. Sometimes I'd discuss an important detail with ChatGPT, decide that we'd settled the issue, and then forget to record the decision anywhere else.
And I made another mistake that didn't seem like a mistake at the time.
I deleted conversations.
Not just one or two, either. Looking back, I probably deleted somewhere around a dozen ChatGPT chats before I realized that those conversations contained information I might actually need again.
At the time, I was thinking of them as completed writing sessions. We'd worked through a scene, discussed something, and moved on. I didn't recognize that we were also making decisions about Falcon Hollow's geography, its people, and its history.
Once those conversations were gone, so were some of the details we'd established in them, at least as far as my ability to retrieve them was concerned.
That certainly didn't make keeping the town straight any easier.
How Far Is It from Falcon Lodge to the Old Mill?
I think one of the moments when the continuity problem really became apparent involved Brooke Allen and her visits to several crime scenes in Father's Day.
Writing a scene inside Cedar Street Cafe was one thing. I could picture the corner restaurant, describe the atmosphere, and concentrate on the conversation taking place there.
But when Brooke needed to travel between locations, suddenly the geography of Falcon Hollow mattered.
How far was Falcon Lodge from the Old Mill? How long would it take to drive from the Old Mill to Falcon Bait and Sandwich Shop? Could she reasonably visit all those locations in the amount of time available?
Those weren't questions I could answer simply by describing a street or inventing another building.
The distances had to make sense.
And if I established a travel time in one chapter, I couldn't have the same trip take twice as long in another chapter without a reason.
The same problem applied to the police department and the medical examiner's office. How far apart were they? How long would Duke Mantz need to travel between them? If officers responded to a particular location, did the route make sense based on what I'd already described?
I began realizing that Falcon Hollow needed something more permanent than my memory and a collection of scattered notes.
Not because I had suddenly decided to create an elaborate fictional world, but because the world I was already describing needed to remain consistent.
The town was developing its own identity through the stories. Streets, businesses, neighborhoods, and familiar places were becoming part of that identity. I didn't need to invent an entirely new town every time a character walked out the door.
I needed to remember the one I'd already created.
Trying to Put Falcon Hollow on Paper
My first attempts at documenting Falcon Hollow were nothing like the reference materials I use today.
I wasn't developing a comprehensive World Bible or establishing a formal system for tracking canon. I was trying to answer practical questions that kept coming up while I wrote.
Where exactly was Cedar Street Cafe? Which direction did Main Street run? How did the different parts of town connect? Where were the police department, the medical examiner's office, and the businesses that appeared in the story?
And, perhaps most importantly, what had I already said about those places?
The information was still scattered, and I was still figuring out what needed to be recorded. But I was beginning to understand that a fictional town required a certain amount of consistency if readers were going to believe in it.
I also discovered that the problem wasn't limited to geography. Characters had histories, relationships, jobs, and personalities. Events occurred on particular dates. Decisions made in one chapter could affect something that happened much later.
Every new detail added another piece to the puzzle.
And because my imagination rarely followed a predictable sequence, I couldn't depend on remembering everything in the order I'd created it.
I needed a way to preserve those decisions, even when my attention had already wandered off to something entirely different.
Almost a Year Later
We're approaching a year since I first started developing Father's Day, and Falcon Hollow has grown far beyond anything I imagined when I wrote that opening sentence.
The town now has a much more established geography, a municipal government, a police department, businesses, schools, neighborhoods, and a growing collection of people whose lives intersect throughout the stories. There's even a satellite-style map and an interactive version on the Falcon Hollow website.
And yet, while discussing this very article, I realized something.
We never put the courthouse on the map.
The courthouse. The place connected to the sentence that started the whole thing.
We've spent countless hours deciding where roads should run, how buildings should face the street, and where the town's various facilities belong. We've placed Town Hall, the post office, the Public Safety Building, the medical center, and practically everything else.
But somehow, the courthouse escaped us.
I suppose that's a fitting reminder that keeping a fictional town consistent is an ongoing process, even when you've spent nearly a year trying to get it right.
Looking back, I don't think the real problem was simply that ChatGPT couldn't remember Falcon Hollow. I couldn't always remember it either. We were developing a community one scene, one conversation, and one unexpected idea at a time, without initially recognizing how much information we were creating.
Eventually, I understood that I needed more than a few notes and a good memory. I needed something I could return to whenever a question came up, something that would preserve the decisions I'd already made instead of forcing me to reconstruct them.
Of course, figuring out how to organize all that information turned out to be another adventure entirely.
And as I would eventually discover, one reference document wasn't going to be enough.
Oh, and by the way, that courthouse where all of this started?
I'm still trying to figure out where I put it.





Comments